Every serious collector faces a choice: Are you in this for the metal, or the rarity? We compare the two paths—bullion (intrinsic value) versus numismatics (collector premium)—to help you choose the best strategy for your investment goals.
Rarity is the heartbeat of value in coin collecting. But what exactly makes one coin worth a few dollars and another worth thousands? Whether you’re new to collecting or evaluating an inherited stash, understanding the factors that make a coin rare is key to appreciating its true worth—and protecting yourself from overpaying or underselling. In this article, we break down the five core elements that contribute to a coin’s rarity and value.