FAQ’s

Answers You Can Trust

Frequently Asked Questions About Collecting, Appraising, And Selling

Whether you’re just starting your collection, inheriting family coins, or ready to sell a lifelong trove of treasures, we know you’ve got questions. At Keywell Collectibles, we believe in honest answers, clear communication, and empowering every client with the knowledge to make confident decisions.

Below, you’ll find answers to the most common questions about coin appraisals, selling, consignment, custom silver pours, and working with us—locally and nationwide.

Start Today!
Explore What We Appraise And Buy

Coins, Currency, and Collectibles

Yes! We offer free overview appraisals for small batches and provide formal, fee-based evaluations for estate or insurance purposes.

No—please don’t! Cleaning coins can significantly reduce their value. We strongly recommend leaving them in their original state.

We appraise and purchase U.S. and foreign coins, currency, precious metals (gold, silver, platinum), jewelry, and even vintage toy cars.

Absolutely. We work with clients nationwide. You can email us photos for small reviews or ship your collection securely for a formal evaluation.

That’s exactly what we help determine. Rarity, condition, demand, and historical significance all play a role—our appraisals help you understand your collection’s real-world value.

Selling, Consigning, Or Evaluating A Collection?

Selling, Consignment, and Trust

We do both. Whether it’s a single coin or an estate-size collection, we can make an offer or help list items on consignment.

You bring or ship your items, and we handle everything—valuation, listing, selling, and shipping. You get paid when the item sells.

We base our offers on current market trends, recent sales of similar items, rarity, and condition. Everything is done transparently.

Yes. All evaluations and transactions are handled with discretion and professionalism—whether in person, at a show, or through secure shipping.

Custom Poured Silver With Character

Mafia Metals: Custom Metal Pouring

Mafia Metals is our custom-poured silver division. Every piece is handcrafted by Armand using fine silver and artisan molds.

Yes! We accept silver bullion for custom pours. A small fee per ounce applies depending on the design complexity.

They are! No two pours are exactly alike. Each bar or shape is hand-finished, making it truly one-of-a-kind.

Where We Operate And How To Begin

Nationwide Service and Next Steps

Yes, for large or estate-size collections. We can meet at your home, bank, or another secure location by appointment.

While headquartered in Michigan, we proudly serve clients nationwide via secure shipping, virtual evaluations, and event meetups.

Simple—just contact us or email photos of your collection. We’ll guide you through next steps based on your goals.